the raoul moat of separation

14 07 2010

They say an Englishman’s home is his castle. Maybe these days it is moral superiority that is our castle. With little frame of reference for moral decisions except ‘my feelings’ and ‘what other people think’, it is easy to retreat to the safe ground of superiority, building a castle around ourselves, a castle of protection from engaging with what is outside and a castle filled with others who think the same. Otherwise we would have to mix with ‘the others’, the dirty ones who live outside my castle who think differently and might taint the purity of our community. They might ask us why we think how we do and we would only be able to answer “because I do” and that would seem childish and inadequate.

Prime Minister David Cameron has said that there should be no sympathy for Raoul Moat. The BBC reports that speaking during Prime Minister’s Question Time, Mr Cameron said:

“It is absolutely clear that Raoul Moat was a callous murderer, full stop, end of story. I cannot understand any wave, however small, of public sympathy for this man. There should be sympathy for his victims and the havoc he wreaked in that community. There should be no sympathy for him.”

Full stop, end of story? Really? Now, I understand how that opinion is formed. Moral indignation is a natural response. Firm leadership is required and Cameron thinks he is giving it. Point the finger, name the act, distance ourselves from it. Simple as.

The trouble is for people who follow Jesus, that simply isn’t good enough. We can of course join in with moral indignation and stamping our feet with the best of them – we are, after all, renowned for that – but we cannot stop there. The train doesn’t stop at Moral Indignation Station, it passes through to somewhere a whole lot more uncomfortable. Namely, Empathy Station. Which is on a branch line with All Fall Short, Cast the First Stone and Love Your Enemy. Those stations are rickety, tumbledown old places, full of weeds and nowhere near as strong and secure-looking as Moral Superiority Castle. But they are beautiful places that manage to hold the tension between someone doing something wrong and why they did it; between the consequences of someone’s actions and the life that led to it. That is a difficult place to be because it is so much easier to blame and point and retreat. But we walk where Jesus walked and he walked there.

I spoke to someone who assaulted someone else recently, and they said that they couldn’t help their anger because it was ‘in their genes’, it was just how the family reacted to situations. It was learned behaviour and inherited behaviour. For me, when Jesus says he has come to loose the chains and free the captives, it is this sort of thing he means. And how can he do that if we feel nothing for those who are held captive, knowingly or unknowingly? It doesn’t mean their actions go unpunished or the consequences ignored – but it does mean that it is our obligation and our duty and our will  and our desire to understand why people do what they do, say what they say; it does not excuse actions like those of Raoul Moat but we must allow ourselves to feel more than self-righteous anger.

What David Cameron has said is outrageous. He needs to come out of Moral Superiority Castle, cross over the stagnant moat of separation and meet the kingdom of God where justice and mercy meet, where the never-ending stream is full of justice and goodness; where people are messed up and broken and dirty like old cracked pots that leak and feel pretty useless and that, that is where we are and where we are a part of the repairing and restoring and transforming of the world. It is a place of tension. It is a place of unresolved hurt.

No-one said that where justice and mercy meet was a comfortable place.


Click here to download We Are Blessed (Bring Heaven to Earth), and let’s move out of the castles, cross the moat and get real.

We Are Blessed (Bring Heaven to Earth)

Bring heaven to earth, Lord
Bring peace where there’s fear
Bring life where there’s death, Lord
Bring joy in these tears

Bring love where there’s lust, Lord
Bring hope where there’s pain
Bring rest where there’s chaos
Bring faith where there’s fame.


You invite us to partner with you
To see your kingdom come


We are blessed, to bless a world in pieces
We are loved, to love where love is not.
We are changed, to be the change you promised
We are freed, to be your hands, O God


Lord we cry out to you
Change the atmosphere
Breathe new life in all who gather here

Bring home to the homeless
Bring keys to the chained
Bring worth to the purchased
And touch to the shamed.
Bring flesh from your word, Lord
Bring truth where there’s spin
Bring risk where there’s safety
And grace where there’s sin

In the broken, we shall see restored
the image of our King

Bring justice to profit
Bring patience to growth
Bring wisdom to progress
Like food for the soul
Bring freedom from debt, Lord
An end to excess
Bring closer your kingdom
By quiet success

May we grow in the knowledge of you
Through every heart and face

© Andy Flannagan

Add to FacebookAdd to DiggAdd to Del.icio.usAdd to StumbleuponAdd to RedditAdd to BlinklistAdd to TwitterAdd to TechnoratiAdd to Yahoo BuzzAdd to Newsvine




4 responses

14 07 2010
Hannah Awesome

Yes totally, how easy it is for us to stand in judgement yet do we not fail ourselves? Maybe not in such an extreme way but we all fail ‘morally’ at times. I’ll never forget when I stood in front of a load of teenage boys in a prison in Brasil, they were nearly all there because they had murdered someone. Did I stand and tremble and think ‘what a horrid place to be standing’. No. I was reduced to tears and a deep sense of compassion for these brothers of mine. Jesus gave me/you grace and continues to do so, surely the least I/we can do is show others the same grace and love.

14 07 2010

And what about us? Wasn’t it us who failed to help him with his struggle? Wasn’t it us that let him out of prison without support. Wasn’t it us that didn’t warn others of the risk? It wasn’t “them” it was the big society. The same society that rushed to criticise the police for their response and pilioried “them”.

And yet I feel very uncomfortable with aged footballers blundering in with messages of love and support that don’t recognise the facts. And of shrines built as if he was a saint, he wasn’t! Because the fact is, whatever our genes and upbringing make of us, at the end of the day what we make of ourselves it is our responsibility and we have to face the consequences, alone.

And we have to face the consequences of the society we have allowed to be built in our name. When will we take responsibility to struggle and to think and to hurt and to cry as we try to work out these tensions? Its easier to argue about the flower rota isn’t it.

16 07 2010
25 07 2010

moet was a brute and a thug which is more common in todays english society,i don’t know of one man on earth who does not dabble in all kinds of porn,even death porn,capture rape and kidnap,there is even violence in main stream porn,i don’t know of one guy who does not go through the seperation process from his family at an age as early as 9!!
And subsequently without supervision,due to both parents being either too lazy or overworked watch porn,this man then grows up with a blantant no show of respect for any kind of woman..
maybe thats why more women than men are getting better grades,as man is the author of his own destruction?

What are you thinking?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: